AtomicAstro's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[CherryBot Hands Out Flyers]

Man that was awesome, the lines were great as usual. The animation really kicked ass. The only thing I didn't like about it was that the cartoon didn't quite make it clear exactly what was happening.

MackleNG responds:

yeaahh, i guess it could be a little hard to make out, it made sense to me but i made it so of course i did, probably would of been best to get some dialogue in on this, thanks for da review

[OneyPlays ANIMATED : GTA 5 with Mods]

Woah I remember you showing progress of this on Skype, it turned out great dude good job.

[Eyes of Heaven.MOV]

Alright well I have no problem with the fact that the voices were from another source, as that's essentially the point of those "_____ animated" cartoons. However, even then this cartoon is not very good. The biggest problem I have with this is the lack of animation. For the most part it's just static images with lip syncing, and I have been guilty of this but I still find that it's a problem worth mentioning. The art was pretty good though, and the colors were nice. I wouldn't say this is the worst thing ever but it has room for improvement.

[The Finding Dory Collab]

I've really come to appreciate these New Wave collabs more lately, ever since Pico Joins the Army. I just love how clear it is that you guys like making these. It makes them so fun to watch. My favorite part was definitely the Dr. Katz part, it was hilarious. I would not say that everything in this was really a hit with me, however I will say that I definitely did enjoy this. Keep up the good work! :)

MobileSpider responds:

we all have big penis!

[Kill La Kill vs. Pokemon : Poke La Mon]

Well, the art is really good. You are an amazing artist. I had some issues in regards to the animation however. For one thing there doesn't even seem to be much animation at all. Granted, in my cartoons I have been guilty of this same mistake, and as such have been taking measures to avoid it in my current cartoon project. My main issue is that for plenty of the movements there were pretty much no inbetweens. The only thing that I saw with inbetweens in this entire thing was one of the Pokemon wagging a tail. Other than that it was just one pose to the next, no inbetweens whatsoever. I'd not recommend doing this because it looks cheap and quite lazy in all honesty. Also the use of tweening on Satsuki's arm when she was directing the Pokemon to attack, as well as Ryuko saying "ugh, moron" after that did not look very good, the one on Satsuki because it was moving seemingly at a constant speed, and the one with Ryuko because it looked kind of like a lifeless puppet in all honesty, same could be applied to Satsuki actually. I'm not saying to condemn the use of tweening altogether, as it doesn't look bad if done well, and can significantly reduce the time you take to animate, I'd just advise trying to use tweening better and more carefully.

[Pico Joins the Army]

This was really good, pretty damn well animated.

[Alzheimer's Cop]

The animation and art were pretty good! The part where they were constantly blaming each other was hilarious, however some of the other jokes were a bit predictable but still got a chuckle out of me.

[Friday The 13th Prank]

It was good, the colors were great. The backgrounds were cool too, especially the one in the beginning. The joke overall had me chuckling ever so slightly but didn't really have me laughing too much, but hey as long as it entertained me to the point of laughing at least a little then it was successful. One particular thing that I wasn't particularly fond of was the background transition to Cameron. I overall never liked frame by frame background transitions, they tend to look bad in my opinion. It would have been fine if the camera just moved onto Cameron with no transition. Overall I liked it.

RedAndrew responds:

Thank you. But I will say about the background transition. Yeah, I might be bad at it, but my whole animation style is made frame by frame. Everything I do is frame by frame, no tweens ever. Course I wanted to do this effect thingy and even if it didn't work. I'll try to make it better next time, still frame by frame.

[A Prank Time]

Holy shit, this is nothing short of excellent. The animation was top notch and really entertaining to look at, very smooth and overall pleasing. It got plenty of chuckles out of me. You sir have a new fan! :)

[The Disgust Collab]

I'm going to be 100% honest... I didn't like it. I found it very boring. It had its moments, but overall it felt very devoid of humor.

MobileSpider responds:

I guess we all forgot to make the cartoon all pretentious sarcasm but we can laugh at life